Conference paper

Interaction-based multi-objective quality assessment for task-specific vacuum grasping

Georg Siegemund, Florian Hecht, Franz Dietrich

Technical University Berlin, Institute of Machine Tools and Factory Management

CIRP Global Web Conference 2026 (CIRPe 2026) — Procedia CIRP · 2026

RoboticsVacuum GraspingGrasp QualityMachine LearningSensor Data
Cover visual for Interaction-based multi-objective quality assessment for task-specific vacuum grasping

Introduction

A geometrically promising suction position is not necessarily the best position once the gripper physically interacts with the object.

Seal formation, leakage, pressure distribution, suction effort, contact force, and local compliance only become observable during the actual grasp. This work introduces an interaction-based, multi-objective framework for evaluating and re-ranking vacuum grasp candidates according to the requirements of a specific handling task.

At a glance

Challenge

Geometric grasp planning and vacuum thresholds provide useful feasibility information but do not fully describe how robust, efficient, or gentle a grasp is.

Approach

Point-cloud-generated candidates are physically executed. Sensor information is transformed into several interpretable grasp-quality components and combined differently depending on the task.

Key result

Only 7.7% top-1 agreement was observed between the initial geometric ranking and the measured interaction-based ranking, showing that physical interaction provides important information that geometry alone cannot capture.

Beyond binary grasp success

Two successful grasps can behave very differently: one may require more suction power, another may create excessive force on the object, and a third may form a more uniform and robust seal.

A simple success/failure label loses this information, even though it is directly relevant to industrial process design.

A multi-objective grasp quality

Grasp quality is broken down into five interpretable components: seal strength, pressure uniformity, suction efficiency, gentle handling (low interaction force), and geometric robustness.

Each component captures a different aspect of how the grasp actually behaved during execution, rather than a single aggregate score.

Geometry proposes, interaction evaluates

The framework works in two stages. First, point-cloud geometry generates plausible grasp candidates for a given object.

Second, these candidates are physically executed and evaluated using real pressure, force, pose, gripper orientation, and suction-command data, producing a measured quality label that can re-rank the original candidate set.

Task-specific grasp selection

The best grasp depends on what the process actually values — robust transport, energy-efficient handling, gentle handling, or precision placement can each favour a different grasp position from the same candidate set.

Weighting the five quality components differently therefore allows the same measured database to serve different task requirements.

Learning from measured grasps

The resulting grasp database, built from physically measured quality labels, can be used as training data for a prediction model.

This demonstrates how measured grasp quality could eventually guide a robot toward promising grasp regions without exhaustively testing every position.

In the paper this stage is a demonstration only: a small neural network shows that the selected grasp position changes with the optimisation objective, without reporting predictor accuracy.

Highlights

Methodology

Findings

Figures

Plate reference and heatmaps of pressure uniformity, gentle handling, and success rate over the grasp grid
Plate reference and quality maps over the grasp grid at 0.30 V and 0° tilt: pressure uniformity, gentle handling, and measured success rate.
Point-cloud grasp rank compared with measured interaction-based quality rank on the test part
Grasp candidates on the test part, ranked by point-cloud geometry (left) and by measured interaction-based quality (right); rank 1 is best.

Method diagram

Two-stage framework: grasp data collection with a grip quality assessment, and grasp position prediction with a neural network
Two-stage framework: grasp data collection with a quality function, and prediction of grasp positions from the resulting grasp database.

Limitations

Citation

Siegemund, G., Hecht, F., & Dietrich, F. (2026). Interaction-based multi-objective quality assessment for task-specific vacuum grasping. Procedia CIRP — CIRP Global Web Conference 2026 (CIRPe 2026).

Related publications

Interested in a research collaboration?

Get in touch to discuss joint research, data collection, or applied evaluation of new methods.

Discuss a collaboration